There are two main strategies we use when shopping for nail polish (or picking a color at the nail salon under pressure). You're either the person who leaves the store with a new bottle and 10 fingers painted different hues, or you grab the first polish name you recognize. Either way, it can be hard to find a shade you love, especially when each brand offers (what feels like) endless color options.
Take, for example, Essie. The popular brand is a salon, pro, and consumer favorite, and many of us are on a first-name basis with popular colors like Clambake and Mademoiselle. But with dozens upon dozens to choose from, you're majorly missing out if you never stray beyond your go-to orangey-red. For help navigating the massive selection, we turned to nail artist Michelle Saunders, who also serves as the brand's official celebrity manicurist (and has an encyclopedic knowledge of its color offerings).
Ahead, Saunders takes a break from her A-list clientele to share her favorite foolproof shades for every skin tone, from everyday nudes and pale pinks to more unexpected brights and, of course, the best reds.
Best Bright For Fair Skin Tones
"This may be much brighter than you're used to wearing, but it's actually pretty classic on the nail," says Saunders. "People constantly ask about this shade when I use it [on shoots]."
Essie Nail Polish in Fiesta, $8.50, available at Essie.
Or Try...
If Fiesta is a little too bright for your liking, a magenta shade like this one will be just as eye-catching. Plus, the polish is part of the brand's new Gel Couture line, which boasts an updated brush stem and a gorgeous Frank Gehry-inspired bottle.
Essie Gel Couture Nail Polish in Sit Me In the Front Row, $11.50, available at Essie.
Or Try...
"If you want to add a little more flair to [Sit Me In the Front Row], you can apply it over a coat of Blanc, Essie's opaque white, and it almost looks neon," Saunders says.
Essie Nail Polish in Blanc, $8.50, available at Essie.
Or Try...
Essie's spring 2016 collection has a host of colors that are perfect for warmer weather. This shade, Sunshine State of Mind, is our go-to hue to sport while lounging poolside.
Essie Nail Polish in Sunshine State of Mind, $8.50, available at Essie.
Or Try...
A cantaloupe hue like this one is a great option for those who want to experiment with brighter nails, but don't want to dive deep into bright reds or pinks just yet.
Essie Gel Couture Nail Polish in Looks To Thrill, $11.50, available in June at Essie.
Best Bright For Medium Skin Tones
"This color looks great on medium skin tones, and I think we're going to be seeing this color more this spring. It's the perfect sky blue," says Saunders.
Essie Nail Polish in Bikini So Teeny, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best Bright For Dark Skin Tones
“This brand-new, super-bright purple called Shades On is probably the most on-trend color to wear right now,” Saunders told us.
Essie Nail Polish in Shades On, $8.50, available at Essie.
Or Try...
"There is a another color that people don’t really know about that I love for [dark skin tones] called Play Date," Saunders says. "It's basically a neon lavender, and it's perfect for pedicures, and I use it all the time for nail art, too."
Essie Nail Polish in Play Date, $8.50, available at Essie.
Or Try...
This indigo shade may look dark in the bottle, but when it's layered onto the nails it provides a pop of shiny, bold color.
Essie Nail Polish in All Access Pass, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best Dark For Fair Skin Tones
"For [those with fair skin who] want to dip their toes into a dark shade, but not go too dark, my pick is Chinchilly," Saunders says. "It's like a deep neutral, almost like a warm gray. There is also this color that I love called Carry On. It feels like a rich, kind of mahogany wine color, which is good for a dark color that is also very on-trend."
Essie Nail Polish in Carry On, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best Dark For Medium Skin Tones
"Wicked is a bit like a plum burgundy, and it's one of the best colors, maybe ever," Saunders says. "I have to say, in my career, Wicked and Mademoiselle are the two most requested colors."
Essie Nail Polish in Wicked, $8.50, available at Essie.
Or Try...
"I [also] love the color Smokin' Hot and the shade Licorice, which is like a patent-leather black," says Saunders. Unfortunately both shades are sold out, but Luxedo (a deep plum) is a great alternative for those looking for vampier hues.
Essie Nail Polish in Luxedo, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best Dark For Dark Skin Tones
"My top pick for deep skin tones is Bahama Mama," Saunders says. "It's flattering for all darker skin tones; I would put that on anybody."
Essie Nail Polish in Bahama Mama, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best White For Medium Skin Tones
Ask any artist: Finding the right shade of white is a surprisingly tricky feat.But Kandalec says there's an easy way to achieve your desired ivory hue. Two coats of Essie's Marshmallow gives a semi-sheer tint, while three coats delivers more opaque coverage.
Essie Nail Polish in Marshmallow, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best Neutral For Fair Skin Tones
"A good overall neutral color for a fair hand is a color like Sugar Daddy. It's a traditional shade that gives your nail bed a healthy, sheer sheen. It's especially great for spring, because we're seeing a lot of pinks that lean on the sheer side," says Saunders.
Essie Nail Polish in Sugar Daddy, $8.50, available at Essie.
Or Try...
Ballet Slippers is another classic "your nails but better" shade. Plus, the sheer, pinkish hue is extremely forgiving, meaning you can swipe it on in a hurry and dash out the door.
Essie Nail Polish in Ballet Slippers, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best Neutral For Medium Skin Tones
"There is a traditional color called Ballet Slippers that is great for medium skin tones, but if you want something that is a bit more on-trend, I love Lady Like," says Saunders. "It looks like a natural flush of color if you apply it on hands [with a medium skin tone]."
Essie Nail Polish in Lady Like, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best Neutral For Dark Skin Tones
"The most traditional color that looks really great on a dark skin tone is Mademoiselle — you just can’t go wrong with that on dark skin," Saunders told us. "But, if you want to go more [trendy], I love this color called Mamba. It's the perfect peachy hue that we're seeing a lot of. I would almost call it a secret color, because not many people know about it."
Essie Nail Polish in Mambo, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best Red For Fair Skin Tones
"For fair skin, there is a color I love called Fifth Avenue," Saunders tells us. "People may look at it and think that it could be too coral, but on the nail it's not; it's a really bright red. I would call it a spring red."
Essie Nail Polish in Fifth Avenue, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best Red For Medium Skin Tones
"I know that people think that this shade, A-list, may be too dark, but I think this is the real red of all of Essie's colors," says Saunders. "It's a true red, and I have had it in my kit forever. It's a classic, traditional red and a cult favorite. It looks great on anyone, and I love it on medium skin tones."
Essie Nail Polish in A-List, $8.50, available at Essie.
Or Try...
Looking for something a little less vampy? You can't go wrong with Russian Roulette.
Essie Nail Polish in Russian Roulette, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best Red For Dark Skin Tones
"A few red colors that I love on dark skin tones are Berry Naughty, Bordeaux, and Lacy Not Racy. If you look them up online, they look very dark, but they go on quite red. Lacy Not Racy is my pick, If you see someone wearing it you can't help but think, Wow, she has really beautiful deep red nails," Saunders says.
Essie Nail Polish in Lacy Not Racy, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best Metallic For Dark Skin Tones
Kandalec’s all-time favorite metallic for dark skin? This amped-up mocha. “It's slight transparency and warm hue reflects a stunning warm glow,” she says.
Essie Nail Polish in Buy Me a Cameo, $8.50, available at Essie.
Best White For Dark Skin Tones
To keep white polish from looking too stark against dark skin, Kandalec suggests choosing a shade with an ivory undertone. This soft cream fits the bill.
Essie Nail Polish in Tuck It In My Tux, $8.50, available at Essie
Like this post? There's more. Get tons of beauty tips, tutorials, and news on the Refinery29 Beauty Facebook page. Like us on Facebook — we'll see you there!
Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?
The Best Of New York Nail Salons